News | 1st Jul, 2011

Death-knell for ‘dirty’ Hazelwood

Friday, 1 July 2011
Adam Morton and Michelle Grattan, The Age

Australia's ''dirtiest'' large coal-fired power station, Hazelwood in the Latrobe Valley, could be bought out and shut down under a carbon price package expected to be announced within weeks.

The Age believes the carbon price deal being brokered by Canberra's multi-party climate committee will include a plan to pay for the closure or conversion to gas of at least one of the nation's greenhouse gas-intensive coal plants over an extended transition period.

Federal Energy Minister Martin Ferguson yesterday flagged the possibility of the government paying to retire Hazelwood, or the smaller Playford plant in South Australia.

The owners of another Victorian plant, Yallourn, have also indicated they would be open to a buyout for the right price.

The developments came as:

  • It was reported that an alliance of powerful industry groups was preparing a multimillion-dollar advertising campaign aimed at scuppering the carbon price plan. Groups involved included the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry and the Minerals Council of Australia.
  • It emerged that the government, in a key concession to the Greens, had agreed to direct $2 billion a year of carbon tax revenue into a renewable energy fund to finance a 17-fold increase in clean power use.
  • Greens leader Bob Brown signalled that his party might have to accept the coal industry receiving compensation to achieve a deal on a carbon price.
  • Prime Minister Julia Gillard sought to rebadge the carbon tax as an emissions trading scheme.

Mr Ferguson, speaking at a Melbourne University conference yesterday, said investment in baseload power had stalled due to financial uncertainty, and it would require a carbon price and the closure of existing coal generators to start spending on lower emissions gas-fired power.

''The key to [investment in cleaner power] is not just the price on carbon,'' he said. ''It's also the potential retirement of some of the legacy generators.''

He said the potential closure of Hazelwood or Playford would lead to ''huge regional adjustment issues in the electricity sector that we will have to manage''.

Hazelwood's owner, International Power, has said it would consider being paid for a phased closure. Its asking price is believed to be about $2.5 billion.

Hazelwood emits about 16 million tonnes of carbon dioxide a year – roughly 3 per cent of national emissions.

Compensation for a coal-fired plant has been a sticking point between the government, Greens and independents. The Greens oppose compensation for coal-fired electricity, but it is believed a compromise has been reached after it was agreed some carbon tax revenue would be conditional on a plant closing.

Senator Brown said that Australia ''shouldn't be giving subsidies or kickbacks to the largely foreign owned and very profitable coal industry.

''But the big parties want it. People have voted for them. I respect the point of view they're putting, and that's one of the issues we're debating.''

The government's climate adviser, Ross Garnaut, softened his opposition to compensation for the owners of coal plants, saying it was not necessary but would not reduce the environmental validity of the scheme.

The proposed clean energy fund would provide seed funding for solar, wind and other projects. The money would be expected to be repaid once projects became financially viable.

Ms Gillard, meanwhile, was seeking to rebadge the carbon tax as an emissions trading scheme after winning support in the cross-party talks to launch a trading regime after three years.

Opposition Leader Tony Abbott accused Ms Gillard of trickery. ''If it looks like a tax, if it works like a tax, if it costs like a tax, it is a tax,'' he said.

Ms Gillard has been dogged by criticism for breaking her pre-election pledge that there would be no carbon tax.

Earlier this year the government said the tax, which starts next year, would be replaced by emissions trading after three to five years, but the deal being hammered out will now include a transition to trading in 2015.

The Prime Minister said yesterday that ''what Tony Abbott likes to refer to as a carbon tax'' was ''a fixed price period for an emissions trading scheme''. She said her aim as Prime Minister had always been to have an ETS. ''That's an aim that I share with John Howard and Malcolm Turnbull,'' she said. ''I've always been determined that the fixed-price period would be as short as possible''

The business community is also anxious that trading takes place as soon as possible. A carbon price deal is expected to be concluded within 10 days.


Read the original article here


Check out our media release here

Get the dirt on our campaign to Replace Hazelwood

And more on our campaign to put a Price on Pollution


Get the dirt on coal in Victoria with CoalWatch